Meeting New Energy Star Energy Efficiency Ratings with ECplus and DCplus Motors
By Simon M Gidney, President
EC Fans & Drives - www.ecdrives.com
In a typical supermarket, refrigeration alone accounts for over 35% of the energy consumed. It has become the object of increasingly stringent legislation targeting the vast energy saving potential of commercial refrigerators and freezers.
Energy Star, the international standard for energy efficiency in consumer products, has mandated that by 2014, refrigerators must use 25% less electricity than current Energy Star models to maintain their Energy Star approved status. To meet these requirements, supermarket procurement departments are increasingly specifying that all new and retrofitted commercial refrigerators and freezers be fitted with electronically commutated motors. Energy Star estimates that replacing all existing commercial solid door refrigerators and freezers in the U.S. with Energy Star qualified models would save $410 million per year or more than 35% percent of the energy consumed by models currently on the market.
Current energy consumption issues stem from old technology. A typical American supermarket has about 400 shaded pole motors in commercial refrigerators and freezers running 100% of the time. The efficiency rate of these motors is in the order of 15%. This means that 85% of their energy consumption is transferred as waste heat into the environment, and has to be removed or cooled down again by the refrigeration and air conditioning system, causing additional consumption of energy.
Figure 1. ECplus Energy Saving Chart vs. Shaded Pole Motor
EC Fans & Drives, a division of Epec, offers two new, proprietary electronically commutated motors ("ECM"), the ECplus and the DCplus. Each of these motors are, on average, 70% to 80% more efficient than the traditional shaded-pole or permanent split capacitor ("PSC") motors that are used in most commercial refrigeration applications.
The ECplus motor, available in either 120VAC or 230VAC format, uses its state of the art electronic circuitry to take the input AC current and convert it into more efficient and flexible DC current.
The DCplus motor on the other hand, is a low voltage DC motor, available in 12, 24 or 48VDC format. The DCplus motor is of particular interest to refrigeration case manufacturers and vending machine manufacturers who have incorporated energy efficient LED lighting systems into their cabinets, as, in order to run LED lights, the units have to already incorporate a low voltage DC power source. The DCplus motor is able to run off the existing DC power supply within the case, thus avoiding the need for either an external power supply or inverter circuitry.
A refrigeration system running on either the ECplus or the DCplus motors would draw a reduced electricity usage of 70% to 80% in comparison with a system running on traditional shaded pole or PSC motors. If this saving in energy cost is multiplied by potentially hundreds of motors in one facility, the actual dollar savings could run to thousands of dollars per month.
The ECplus and DCplus motors' energy efficiency can be attributed to their flexibility. The ECplus is the only EC motor of its class that has three pre-set speeds that can be selected for each application in a band ranging from 600 to 2300 rpm. The DCplus motor is available with 0-10V speed control as standard. This is in contrast to the traditional shaded pole or PSC motors that have historically powered refrigeration evaporator fans which run full speed, 24 hours per day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. Because there is no ability to slow the motor down to take into account night time operation or change in ambient temperatures, these motors are always on and are always drawing maximum power.
When the cooler or freezer temperature is stable - that is, not requiring maximum output from the refrigeration system - the ECplus or the DCplus motor equipped system can reduce the motor speed by half, thus further drastically reducing power consumption.
Figure 2a. ECplus Motor Inside Schematic
Figure 2b. ECplus Motor
Further, the consequential impact of the ECplus or DCplus motors on the operation of the compressor in the cooler or freezer also contributes to energy efficiency. When the temperature in the cooler or freezer is stable and the compressor is not under load, the motor can be switched to low speed – this allows the compressor to cycle less frequently and to operate more efficiently, thus increasing the life and reliability of the compressor and reducing maintenance costs.
The ECplus or DCplus motor can also significantly reduce internal operating temperatures. Due to the inefficiency of shaded pole or PSC motors, their use in a commercial refrigeration system will actually increase the internal temperature of the refrigeration unit. The EC motor has no metallic brushes to create a magnetic field – it uses electronic commutation technology to sense the rotor position and switch supply accordingly – the lack of brushes means that less heat is generated by the operation of the motor itself, thus lowering power consumption and significantly increasing reliability and life expectancy.
Figure 3. ECplus Motor Inside Custom Fan Ring
As refrigeration companies scramble to make their machines meet the Energy Star requirements that go into effect next year, energy efficient electronically commutated motors like the ECplus and DCplus will be popular solutions to making existing refrigeration units meet these qualifications.